
Starring: Sean Penn, Tim Robbins
Directed by Eastwood
Mystic River was supposed to be Clint’s return to Oscar glory. The intense, multi-layered drama had an all-star cast and Clint firing on all cylinders with a script about the mystery surrounding the murder of a young woman in middle-class Boston. Mystic River received multiple nominations (including Best Picture and Best Director) but when awards season rolled around, Clint ran into the buzz saw that was Lord of the Rings and the film walked away with only a couple of awards.
Sean Penn, the Kevin Bacon, and Tim Robbins were childhood buddies, playing street ball and other concrete-related activities. One day when one of the boys was abducted for a few days, the innocence of youth is lost and repercussions are still felt years later. As adults, Sean has (somewhat) put his thug past behind him and Kevin joined the force. Tim just kinda mopes around all day. Then one fateful evening, Sean’s teenage daughter disappears and the three friends are pulled back together once again.
Sean grieves and regresses back into his old ways. Kevin interviews suspects and talks to his estranged wife on his cell phone. Tim kinda mopes around all day. Old wounds are opened up again, secrets are revealed, and stories begin to unravel. Heavy stuff that don’t really make for an enjoyable film, but one that is certainly deserving of all the praise it received.
The truly disturbing performance in the film is from Marcia Gay Harden. As the wife of Tim, she becomes suspicious of her husband’s story about being bloodied and mugged on the night of the murder. As Tim struggles with his own demons, her eventual betrayal ends Tim up on the short end of a beat down at the docks. Sean has lost the only pure love he has known in his life, has killed the wrong man, and ends up the new kingpin on the block. Kevin gives him a good stare down though.
Clint has developed into a real actor’s director. In recent years, he has won Oscars for Gene Hackman, Hilary Swank, Morgan Freeman; and nominations for Meryl Streep, Marcia Gay Harden, and a couple for himself. This film won a Best Actor award for Sean and Supporting Actor for Tim. Now, Sean does a fine job and career-wise is probably deserving of an Oscar or two. But this particular year, Bill Murray gave a subtle performance in Lost in Translation that deserved recognition. Bill got robbed, and my enthusiasm for the Academy Awards has never been the same since.